Mechanical VS Rubber-Dome Switches


During this age of technology, our very own lives revolve around computers for banking, shopping, business and so on. For us humans, we need a way to interface with them to do our stuff and that peripheral we use is the keyboard. There are many debates about mechanical and rubber-dome switches. This is an in-depth review of each to tell about the pros and cons.

Let’s talk about how each works individually. How mechanical switches work is that when you press the key, you press the switch. The switch will register the keystroke and send the signal to the computer. Rubber-Dome is when there are three layers of plastic membranes lying right beneath the keys. When the top and bottom layers connect as the middle layer separates them, the electrical circuit is completed. That particular circuit will transmit the complementary input to the computer.

One huge difference between rubber-dome and mechanical switches is that rubber-dome is way cheaper to produce than mechanical. It is easier and quicker to manufacture keyboards with a single monoblock switch instead of individual keys. They are more resistant to liquids but they do not produce much tactile feedback for each key press. People can refer to the number keypad on a microwave as an example as it also uses rubber-dome switches.

Mechanical switches will generally minimize typos but that depends on the variation of that mechanical switch. Whenever users press on a key, they will feel a very satisfying tactile bump and click. This will help tell the user that the keystroke has been registered. Many programmers enjoy this so they do not need to back track and hunt for their mistake. Rubber-dome switches are rather silent and don’t offer tactile feedback so the user might not even know that the keystroke was whether or not registered.

In terms of durability, mechanical switches prove to be dominant in this area. They generally last at least 10 whopping million keystrokes. This durability soars way above the rubber-dome switches as they last around 5 million keystrokes. Even when the switch breaks, users can easily switch it out for a new one. This is extremely versatile as keycaps can be replaced when broken on a mechanical switch. Keycaps on rubber-domes are much harder as companies do not produce much since rubber-dome keyboards are very cheap.

Another keystone is the clickity clackity. Mechanical keyboards are usually louder and more satisfying than rubber-dome keyboards. It will most definitely help fast typers or book-keepers when recording numbers. Sometimes, this can be a downside as the clicking sounds can distract workers or workmates. Some of these keyboards say that they can ease the pain of RSI or Repetitive Strain Injury.

Overall, mechanical switches are the way to go. Though they may be more expensive, what they offer justifies the cost. The benefits are much less of mistakes, better durability, replaceable keycaps, amazing tactile feedback and better actuation points. If you have or like mechanical switches, click here to learn more about MX Cherry switches

One Comment

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published.